Makers of Change

Lasting change is made by large numbers of ordinary people. People are the solution, and circularity can pay them the way it gets paid: over time.

Share
Naturalist-style painting of honeybees building fresh wax comb on a branch, the hexagonal cells finished at the center and still shallow and half built at the growing edge.
Many makers, a common goal. Image generated by Midjourney.

Change takes people

In August 1940, four months before Franklin Roosevelt asked America to become "the great arsenal of democracy," the government started a program called Training Within Industry. Skilled workers were leaving for the services, and plants were filling with motivated but inexperienced people. The program's answer was to teach supervisors how to teach. Its first course ran ten hours and fit on a card small enough for a shirt pocket. Its rule for growth took one sentence: "Develop a standard method, then train the people who will train other people." By the time it closed in 1945, it had issued 1,750,650 certificates in more than 16,000 plants.

Japan did something similar for quality. In April 1962, the Union of Japanese Scientists and Engineers launched a journal for factory foremen and invited them to form small groups to study problems in their own work. The first quality control circle registered the next month. By 1980, the registry counted more than a million participants.

The pattern holds outside business. Methodism grew out of classes of about twelve neighbors, each under a leader who was not a minister. The first classes formed in Bristol in 1742 to collect a penny a week toward a building debt. Like Toyota's kanban, a small routine did the propagating. American Methodists numbered about 4,900 in 1776 and nearly 1.2 million by 1850.

A Slip of Change — The Circudyne Letter
Lean's revolution ran on a slip of paper. Circularity's will need one too, and the place to find it is the last moment of a product's first life.

Alcoholics Anonymous, founded in 1935, counts about two million members. Its traditions say it should remain "forever nonprofessional." Its guidance on sponsorship is plain: "any A.A. member can become a sponsor."

Set side by side, these cases share three things. The training is counted in hours. The doctrine is short enough to fit in a pocket. And the person at the scene is trusted to act. Armies learned that third lesson the hard way. In 1869, the Prussian general Helmuth von Moltke instructed his commanders that an order should contain only what a subordinate could not work out for himself. United States Special Operations Command puts its version first among its truths: "Humans are more important than hardware."

A voice for some, a squeeze for others

As a consultant, I saw my share of wins and losses. In one engagement, at a large enterprise with many line employees, Lean gained purchase. The people doing the work had less rework to do, and took pride in their continuous improvement. For them the method was a feedback channel, a way to say what was broken and see it fixed. They felt focused.

In another, the work fell to mid-level managers who were measured on numbers and ended up forcing outcomes to fit them. They felt squeezed. It was the opposite of what one might expect. The people with less rank experienced the change as a voice, and the people with more experienced it as an imposition.

America ran this experiment at scale. By 1982, 44% of companies with more than 500 employees had quality circles, most of them started in the previous two years. Within a few years the enthusiasm had faded. Edward Lawler and Susan Mohrman, who studied the decline for Harvard Business Review, found that the circles had no authority to carry out their own ideas, and that middle managers often resisted them. Form by itself is not enough; it needs permission to succeed.

Six Sigma took a different route to large numbers. It is a fine discipline, and General Electric reported training more than 100,000 people in it. Many readers of this letter earned a belt, and wore it proudly. But notice how the people were moved. By the account of Mikel Harry, the consultant who coined the title, "Black Belt" was chosen at one plant because a manager thought he could sell it. At GE, the training became a condition of promotion and of stock options. The method reached people as a credential and a requirement.

The older way was slower but more engaged. "The trainer must actually take the hands of the workers and teach them," wrote Taiichi Ohno, who built Toyota’s production system.

Why good evidence does not move the leader

People provide the proof. A newcomer to AA meets someone who has stayed sober. A Methodist class was led by a neighbor. A line worker can watch the rework fall. Nothing persuades a person like someone similar who has already made the change.

That kind of evidence travels sideways. It does not, by itself, compel the person at the top, and I don't think the reason is a lack of courage. AA and the early Methodists governed themselves and answered to their own members. A public company answers to others. Its leaders hold covenants with shareholders, lenders, customers and employees, and those covenants are controlled by data. The data describes the path the company is already on. It has nothing to say about the path not yet taken.

This is why the usual remedy disappoints. A small circularity pilot can prove that a product works. It cannot prove that a business model works, so it does not hold a leader's interest for long. It also employs a handful of people, when the change needs thousands. The venture world's habit is to put volume first and find the monetization later. That suits software, with its near-zero marginal cost. Circularity deals in real stuff. The way it makes money has to be worked out first.

The new way of making money is simple to state. The fully circular company earns across the whole life of the product. The longer the product endures, the easier it is to maintain, and the longer it appeals to one customer after another, the more the company should thrive. It is a revolutionary and necessary idea, because it lines up incentives over time. The producer is rewarded at every touchpoint, by whoever has the product, whenever they have it.

Revolutionary, but not new. The clearest example is more than sixty years old. In 1962, operators of a new British business jet were offered something unusual for its Viper engines: a complete engine and accessory replacement service, for a fixed cost per flying hour. It was called Power by the Hour. Rolls-Royce, which acquired the Viper’s maker four years later, holds the trademark and has built its service business on the idea.

Consider what the arrangement does. A large uncertainty, an engine that needs unplanned work, becomes a predictable cost that rises and falls with flying. The maker is paid only for engines that perform, so every hour of durability, efficiency and ease of repair it builds in comes back as income. Both parties now want the same thing: an engine that stays on the wing, so the aircraft earns its keep and the operator can serve its own customers dependably. The maker’s advantage has become the customer’s.

In the circularity businesses I know, the product comes back. Whatever the company gets wrong returns to its own people as rework, so they care about quality at every level. The return is a feedback channel, and it comes built in.

That leaves the question of how the people themselves are paid. In the late linear economy, exceptional rewards tend to arrive as windfalls, the exit above all. What if that were no longer so? What if people earned through profit sharing, in step with the quality of their work? A company paid as its products hold up could pay its makers the same way. GE had to attach its incentive to the method. Here the incentive is the business.

None of this makes leaders less necessary. People are a leader's infantry for change, and infantry appreciates, and demands, good leadership. Good followership and good leadership depend on each other. The leader's part is to state the intent, as Moltke asked, and to build the kind of business in which acting on it pays.

The takeaway

People are the solution, not the problem. Give them a channel, a card, and a share.

Next week: Drivers of Change.

💬 Discuss: mention @christian@circudyne.com on Mastodon

Below the line are practitioner insights reserved for Dynamo members — the people building plenty with us. If you're reading as a guest, you're welcome here. But the best seats are saved for the builders. Join the Dynamos